Cruise Line Fans: Cruise Reviews and Chat From Real Cruisers   -   Centrum Deck   -   Cruise Polls   -   First Time Cruisers -- Are 3-Night Cruises Enough to Make a Decision?

Welcome to Cruise Line Fans! ~ Register today to remove this box!
..e

Register For Free and Post Your Questions!

Already a Member? Forgot Your Password?!

Register to make this box go away.




View Poll Results: Is a 3-Night cruise enough time for a "newbie" to decide if he likes cruising?
Yes -- Good to test the waters .... 17 34.00%
NO -- Not enough time for a REAL cruise experience! 28 56.00%
Maybe/Maybe Not 4 8.00%
Never Cruised ... Looking forward to your opinions! 1 2.00%
Voters: 50. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 09-21-2008, 08:47 PM houch is offline     #31 (permalink)
I sure don't think 3 days is enough. One day you are boarding and un packing, then one day to see and experience the whole ship, then you are packing and getting off early in the am! I just can't imagine a 3 day cruise.

My first was 7 days and that didn't seem to be enough. On our 15 day Panama Canal we had a first timer with us and she loved it.

My Signature
Carol ....................



Cruise Countdown princess
Emerald Princess Mediterranean in
Past Cruises Emerald Princess Aug/Sept 08 Mediterranean Star Princess Sept.07 Baltic Sun Princess Jan, 07 Southern Caribbean Sun Princess Nov, 05 Southern Caribbean Celebrity Infinity Apr, 05 Hawaii Grand Princess Mar, 04 Western Caribbean Sun Princess Feb, 03 Panama Canal Sea Princess Nov, 02 Southern Caribbean Ocean Princess Jan, 01 Southern Caribbean Majesty of the Seas Nov, 1999 Southern Caribbean Regal Princess July 1995 Alaska


Old 09-22-2008, 04:44 PM cruisin' chick is offline     #32 (permalink)
Quote:
Originally Posted by houch View Post
I sure don't think 3 days is enough. One day you are boarding and un packing, then one day to see and experience the whole ship, then you are packing and getting off early in the am! I just can't imagine a 3 day cruise.

My first was 7 days and that didn't seem to be enough. On our 15 day Panama Canal we had a first timer with us and she loved it.
My hubby basically said this the other day: that three days is not enough. But then he's been on three day cruises, and now that he's done a 15-day one, he admits to being spoiled.

For a first timer, I still would recommend a shorter one, just in case they find they really don't like this kind of vacation.

My Signature Patty the Roving CLF Guide & Future Ya Ya Princess Stick Shift

Please ask questions! No frus, please!

photos Happy B-Day, Girl!
Cruise Countdown princess
A much needed beach getaway!!!! in 12 Years Married Now!
Past Cruises Carnival Jubilee - Mex. Riv. 1/94, Sensation - W. Car. 11/94, Holiday (2x's) Baja Calif. while preggers 3/97, w/toddler 7/99, Paradise - E. Car. 3/01, Ecstasy - Baja Calif. 6/02; Princess Star - Mex. Riv. 2/03, Sapphire - Alaska 8/04; Island Princess - Hawaii 12/05


Old 09-22-2008, 11:05 PM nealberk is offline     #33 (permalink)
How can you NOT like it?

My Signature Neal (International Association of Troublemakers)

“Patriotism is supporting your country all the time, and your government when it deserves it.”- Mark Twain
Cruise Countdown HAL
Noordam, Dec 7,2008 in 62days 2hours 50minutes
Past Cruises HAL Veendam Celebrity Century Celebrity Constellation


Old 09-22-2008, 11:46 PM reggierail is offline     #34 (permalink)
Talking

Quote:
Originally Posted by packercruising View Post
That was for Seawench but it's great to see inelligent OLD members too!
Is that old as in age or that I've been here for 3 years?

Either way I fit the bill.

My Signature
CLF Celebrity Guide PM me with your Questions
Serenade 10-3-08 Pride 11-02-08 Mariner 4-19-09
The Travel Place, Valencia, Ca. 1-800-688-4933
Cruise Countdown royal carribbean
RCCL Monarch B2B in gone cruising
Past Cruises Viking Serenade ( 3 times ), Serenade Voyager OTS, Vision OTS, Monarch OTS (16 times), Majesty OTS, Rhapsody OTS (2 times), NCL Sea, NCL Star, Mercury ( 4 times ), Infinity, Sapphire, Paradise, Spirit


Old 09-22-2008, 11:56 PM sk8erguy1978 is offline     #35 (permalink)
I voted maybe/maybe not...

Our first cruise was 3 days, I was not sure I would like it, but always wanted to try it.. The G/F's sister booked it all.

Anyway we loved it, but really did not know what we loved about it, so we booked a 5 day within a month of returning from our 3 day and sailed 7 months later. That was good, but not long enough, I think Min should be 7 days... but to determine if you like it 3 days might be enough it might not... Like I said it was enough that we knew we wanted to try again and see why we loved it, so we did the 5..

We still are not 100% sure why we love it, and I do not think we ever will know why we love it, but we are just going to keep on booking

I tell people cruising is like having kids - you just do not know what it is like until you do it... Pardon the pun LOL

My Signature Next cruise March 28th, 2008 celebrating 30th birthday!!!
Past cruises: (***Note Links will take you out of CLF to Google's Picasa photo albums***)
Bahamas - January 28th, 2007 - Pictures
Bermuda - September 9th, 2007 - Pictures


Old 09-23-2008, 11:32 AM Texashorselady is offline     #36 (permalink)
I voted "NO" and here's why:

1) 3 days not long enough to ever get in the spirit of the cruise. Day 1 you are arriving, Day 2 you try to cram in everything you might want to do, and Day 3 you're preoccupied with having to pack up and go home. That hurry-up stressed-out feeling is not typical of what most cruises are like...on such a short cruise you will barely get to relax or soak up the atmosphere.

2) You're going to get a different crowd of people on a cruise that short.

Families who can't get away because of the kids will take the kids with them on a short cruise, because of the short time away from school or activities. So you'll have more children onboard. People who just want to party hearty will take a short cruise...so you'll have more rowdy people onboard. People who are on extremely tight budgets can only afford short cruises...and that might also effect the atmosphere onboard.

Not that there's anything wrong with any of those things...the children, the party crowd, or people on super-tight budgets...but when you put all those factors together on one short 3 day cruise I don't think you could call that a typical cruise. And if you base whether or not you might like cruising on that 3-day cruise experience you could be way off base.






So no, I don't think a 3 day cruise would not be a good way to decide whether you like cruising or not...because you won't be getting the true feeling of what it's like.

My Signature Member of the Old School Frubal Club:
If you get a frubal from me - it really means I appreciate your post. And if I get a frubal from you - I hope I earned it!


Old 09-23-2008, 12:25 PM daWoods is offline     #37 (permalink)
I agree with Julie. 7 day minimum to really get the "cruise" experience. 10 days is better, but you'll come to that decision on your own.

My Signature

Emerald Princess & Lago Mar pictures
http://community.webshots.com/user/woodbrown

3 weeks in Hawaii, March 2009 Woo Hoo!
Cruise Countdown princess
3 weeks in Hawaii in March 2009 in 148days 16hours 15minutes
Past Cruises Norwegian Sky 2001 Grand Princess 2002 Island Princess 2004 Enchantment of the Seas 2005 Sun Princess 2006 Emerald Princess 2008


Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

Cruise Line Fans: Cruise Reviews and Chat From Real Cruisers   -   Centrum Deck   -   Cruise Polls   -   First Time Cruisers -- Are 3-Night Cruises Enough to Make a Decision?
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On






Free Drug Card