We've been to Antigua a bunch of times over the years! Love taking catamarans there!

Between the two you listed ... you might want to give #2 a serious thought for a very good time. Think Princess has it listed as "Circle Antigua By Sea With Lunch" and has their C.R.U.I.S.E. Award. We've never been on a Princess Catamaran Shore excursion with the C.R.U.I.S.E. Award that was not good!

Also, your DH will see nil to no proverty by water ... not that I ever noticed much at all except for right in town.

I haven't been on this exact excursion ... but did do one very similar and very much enjoyed it!

Register At CruiseLineFans.com For Free