I haven't done any of those tours, but I have made the complete transit of the Canal as well as the partial as far as Gatun Lake from the Atlantic side on the cruise ship.

If you want the experience of the canal, my choice would be to do tour #4 to actually transit through the locks and see how they work up close and personal. Hopefully, someone here is familiar with those tours and can give you some first hand info.

Register At CruiseLineFans.com For Free